Sunday, December 6, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes - #98 –December 9, 2009
Communication Quotes of the Week
“Act as if what you do makes a difference. It does.”
William James (1842-1910) was a pioneering American psychologist and philosopher
who trained as a medical doctor. He wrote influential books on the young science of psychology, psychology of religious experience and mysticism, and the philosophy of pragmatism. He was the brother of novelist, Henry James.
(Wikipedia)
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, December 9, 2009 – Room 223
“Moral Decay and The Need for a Dress Code”
Recently, Charles Mason gave me a copy of an academic article entitled “Moral Crisis in Higher Education and the Dress Code Phenomenon.” The article reviews “indecent dressing among youth today” and “the need to restore high moral standards, integrity and decency.” In one of our recent sessions, the topic of saggy pants stirred up much discussion. Some people feel strongly – pro and con - about the way certain people dress. We try to keep calm during the session.
A Note to Communicators:
Ethos
William James’ quote at the top speaks volumes to Communicators. He uses “Act” as “behavior with a purpose.” He suggests that our behavior should always be purposeful. Moreover, James believes, if our behavior becomes conscious, then we should behave as if everything we do matters and has consequences.
[Actors are familiar with the premise of “as if.” This Stanislavski principle allows the actor to create behavior that appears to be “real” in the eyes of the audience.]
Most of time we are not aware of how we behave, how we act. In reality, we are not fully conscious. Only when it is drawn to our attention are we suddenly put in a spotlight.
Public speaking is certainly one Communication behavior that puts us under a real or imagined spotlight. That’s a major reason for stage fright, a topic we discussed in the previous blog.
However, James speaks to “acting” as behaving in everyday life. He argues that our everyday behavior matters. We don’t have to be conscious of our behavior to have it matter. Our non-verbals are always sending a whopping 93% of the meaning of our messages whether we like it or not.
[The 7%, 38%, 55% Rule: According to Albert Mehrabian, the messages we sent in three ways – our words, our voice and our non-verbal behavior. The meaning of our message carried three ways:
7% by the words we used;
38% by our voice;
55% by our non-verbal behavior – facial expression, eyes, hand gestures and body
posture.
“The 3 Vs of Delivery – Verbal, Vocal and Visual”. That means 93% of the meaning of our message is NOT carried by words, the pride and joy of English teachers.
Mehrabian, now an emeritus professor t UCLA, published his landmark book, “Silent Messages” in 1971. cf. Wikipedia]
James is referring to that 93% of our communication. When we meet people and talk with them, our words are really secondary. What counts is our energy as we relate to another.
Since women are typically more sensitive to energy than men (*Don’t argue with me yet!), they pick up on energy more quickly. Actors and dancers are trained to be more sensitive to non-verbals.
[*At another time we’ll talk about some aspects of gender communication which are challenging under the best of conditions.]
The energy we project as we communicate creates an impression. That impression is called “Ethos.” In simple terms we can call it “personality.” We all know that some people have personalities which jump out at us and some whose personality disappears into the woodwork.
We feel and experience “Ethos” but we rarely call attention to it. The American vernacular of the 60s called it “vibes.” The Chinese call it Chior Q’i. British playwright George Bernard Shaw and French philosopher Henri Bergson call it élan vital.
That Ethos or energy that we project can be very persuasive. We respond to positive Ethos. We withdraw from negative Ethos. And all the variations in between.
Ethos is one of the three ways that we persuade, according to Greek philosopher Aristotle. The other two are logos (logic) and pathos(emotion). We only study one of the three in school and that not very well. Courses in “Critical Thinking” approach an understanding of logic, which is an aspect of the topic.
However, we recognize Ethos is our daily lives. Liking or disliking a person is often based on Ethos – the subliminal messages or vibes or energy or Chi or élan vital. We are conscious of our Ethos on a date, in a sales situation – any where and any time we want to make a positive impression
· The phrase, “You don’t have a second chance to make a first impression” speaks to Ethos.
· In sales, it’s called “selling the sizzle, not the steak.’
· The Harvard lawyer Alan Dershowitz believes that the “music” of an argument in court is more persuasive that the words. In other words, we can get fooled.
But again, Ethos can often be skin deep. The package looks lovely, but once you open it, there’s nothing inside.
But that’s another story.
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
December 16 – “Thinking”- Do we know when we think? Can you NOT think? Do you know how YOU think? Do you like to think? Then what do you think about? How can you direct your thinking? What about distractions? These are only some of the topics that will probably come up during the discussion. Maybe someone will know how to read our minds.
December 23 – No club meeting today – We are taking a holiday hiatus and return after the New Year. Enjoy!
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“Meaning”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Repetition”
“Cynicism”
“Heroism”
“Leadership”
“Concentration”
“Student Needs”
“Current Events”
And dozens of others!
What happened on Wednesday, December 9, 2009? “Walking the Talk”

Here is the notice of the session to compare with what really happened!
Last night (12/1), President Obama announced his military and diplomatic intentions about the war in Afghanistan at West Point. He says he wants to “finish the job.” We shall see if he can walk his talk.
- Many of us have had the experience of knowing people who promise to do something and don’t do it. This experience can be personal or within a group. A Touro Dean once described two categories of participants in a project. “There are the show horses and there are the work horses.” The show horses talk a good game, but they “don’t deliver the mail,” as one member of Congress recently phrased it. There are dozens of ways this situation occurs. We’ll share our experiences and then discuss what to do about the phenomenon.
We had a lively group as usual with everyone willing to share their views. One newcomer Ephraim Smith was welcomes by familiar faces included Pamela Sheppard, Richard Green, Jean Missial, Shawn Odle, Carlisle Yearwood, Damian Forbes, Erica Bell, Britzia Bolanos, Drani Gabu, Ronald Johnson, Charles Mason and Hal Wicke.
Hal’s intention was to talk about President Obama’s important Afghanistan speech as an example of our leader putting himself in a public position of “Walking his talk.” As it happened we got so involved in our local issues that we forgot to bring it up. We’ll make sure it is part of a future club session.
Before we got started, Lorinda announced that Midtown was going to have a Toys for Tots drive for the holidays. The deadline for bringing in the toys is the last week before vacation.
Hal’s asked for the inevitable definition of what “Walking the Talk” means. Most seemed to understand the term as “doing what you say you’re going to do.”
Immediately, we got into some of the many reasons why some people aren’t able to do what they say they’re going to do. Some of the reasons why people don’t walk their talk included:
· The most popular reason was that people lie – they don’t tell the truth.
· They are distracted and don’t remember.
· They are “disabled by emotion.”
· They don’t want to be embarrassed by not being able to do what they promised.
· They want to “make nice” and not hurt anyone’s feelings.
· They want to be “OK.”
· Jean said he was a “big picture guy” and does not focus on the details of a project.
Several people shared their family histories of coming to America or growing up in poverty. Some found that their expectations of fulfilling the “American Dream” were disappointed. They wanted things to be better but America was not what they thought it would be before they got here. They said they couldn’t “walk their talk” because of circumstances beyond control – lack of English, money, health issues, family problems. Others felt they had made a commitment for themselves and for their children and were determined to fulfillment at great sacrifice.
· Poor life experiences create a fear of taking a chance, making a commitment.
Erica spoke about teaching her child to use the dictionary and encyclopedia regardless of the availability of the information on the Internet. She felt things have become too easy for many children and she wanted to ensure that her child didn’t have to depend on the computer
Carlisle spoke about the power of the inner voice which guides our actions.
The question was asked, “How DO you walk the talk?”
· Pamela said she writes down goals for herself and ticks them off as she completes them
· Lorinda said that her stable of artists (she is a producer of concerts, among other things) often need “mothering” to achieve their goals. She becomes the “mother” to get the show on.
· Drani told the story of a friend who prepared for a job interview by smoking marijuana against his advice. The friend didn’t get the job.
With Drani’s story, the discussion focused on job interviews where the employer must ascertain whether the potential employee must walk his/her talk. What do you as an employer look for? Here are some of the employment standards and contrasting management styles we shared:
· Damian looks for competence and credibility.
· Someone said the ability to accept criticism
· Lorinda looks for whether they can “perform” – do the show according to a certain level.
· Charles looks for whether the person can think on their feet.
· Ephraim wants the person to be competent.
· Shawn compared the “book way” and the “real way.” Doing well in school doesn’t mean that people will do well in the work force. “I can’t afford to waste time,” he said.
Jean looks for a person he can train to do the level of work he expects. [He is in charge of security for Louis Vuitton on Fifth Avenue.] He trains them the way he was trained. For example, to test an applicant’s patience, he makes them wait 45 minutes before interviewing them. Lateness and malingering with the cellphone and text messaging are some of the behavior he looks for. He gives new employees 90 days to prove themselves.
Dean Kampel asks the employee if they are able to walk their talk. She was looking for their leadership style. She describes all the basic ground rules – lying, cheating, being a bully. She works with minimal rules and thinks of the employee as part of a team. Her supervisory role is to protect her team so the work can get done. She asked the group “What do you do about recognizing someone who is “slick’ at interviewing?” No one could come up with a quick response. [Recognizing “slicksters” is a sophisticated process.]
· Several wanted respect from their employees.
· Carlisle felt that image was everything. One should do nothing to tarnish one’s image. He was using “image” in the sense of “reputation.”
· Hal offered Henry Kissinger’s observation that “Perception IS reality.”
· Drani told of his experience applying for a job as a mechanic for Mercedes. He knew nothing but was willing to learn. He commuted 60 miles round trip to get the job on Long Island.
· Pamela told of her experience working in jewelry store.
· Hal spoke of the Work Study Training program that Lorinda was about to begin at Midtown.
· Dean Kampel spoke of her doctoral work on women and leadership. A possible future topic.
In the “What Did I learn” segment, Drani observed that students were not taught how to learn and how to deal with the outer world. “We need training in this area,” he said.
Other people made brief comments, but the meeting had run until 4:30 pm and their comments were lost in the shuffling.
Clearly, another topic worth exploring.
We are making progress in our communication. We are slowly learning a common vocabulary through the building of the common shared experience. Charles Borkhuis told Hal after his recent session how impressed he was with the level of discussion.
Maybe only a guest can observe how well we are doing because we are too close to the developing process. My hope is that the quality of discussion translates into the classes that every student takes.
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.

Hal Wicke

Sunday, November 29, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes - #97 –December 2, 2009
Communication Quotes of the Week
Here are several quotes about the emotion of fear that underlie “Stage Fright”
The German Proverb – “Fear makes the wolf bigger than he is."
The Japanese proverb – “Fear is only as deep as the mind allows.”
One of the most famous quotes about fear is from President Franklin Delano Roosevelt
in his first inaugural address, March 4, 1933.
The only thing we have to fear is fear itself - nameless, unreasoning, unjustified, terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance."
Then the phrase derived from the word “FEAR”:
F--FALSE
E--EVIDENCE
A--APPEARING
R--REAL
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, December 2, 2009 – Room 223
“Walking the Talk”
Last night (12/1), President Obama announced his military and diplomatic intentions about the war in Afghanistan at West Point. He says he wants to “finish the job.” We shall see if he can walk his talk.
- Many of us have had the experience of knowing people who promise to do something and don’t do it. This experience can be personal or within a group. A Touro Dean once described two categories of participants in a project. “There are the show horses and there are the work horses.” The show horses talk a good game, but they “don’t deliver the mail,” as one member of Congress recently phrased it. There are dozens of ways this situation occurs. We’ll share our experiences and then discuss what to do about the phenomenon.
A Note to Communicators:
Stage Fright
Strategy: To observe people who are under pressure in public situations.
Tactic: To detail the behavior that others exhibit – verbal and non-verbal – which indicates a high degree of excitement.
It’s called a lot of things – “Nervous,” “Performance Anxiety.” “Reluctant speaking.” Many studies have been done on the phenomena. However, “Stage Fright” is a universal experience. Lots of people have lots of different opinions. Here’s mine.
Who gets “Stage Fright”? Everyone: actors, politicians, teachers, The person who says he doesn’t get “Stage Fright” is not in touch with his feelings. Once I had a student who said he was not nervous when he got up in front of a group. He was clever enough to mask the external symptoms – sweaty palms, stammering, shaking hands, wobbling knees. But if you listened carefully to his words they were a sophisticated form of “word salad.”
Why does it happen? There are many theories. My observation is that “Stage Fright” occurs whenever there is a deadline. The closer you get to the deadline, the greater the fear.
Think about those occasions besides public speaking when you get “Stage Fright.” You are planning a dinner or a party. You are getting married. You suddenly find out you’ve got an Academy Award.
It is often said that a person facing death gets an extreme form of “Stage Fright.” The elements are there – a deadline, finality. The mind focuses with unusual clarity.
When does it happen? When you are prepared. When you are unprepared. When you are surprised by something positive or negative. When you do something you know is highly risky.
A personal anecdote: Recently, I was held up at gunpoint on my block. I was very aware of how nervous both robbers were while one held me in a headlock while the other frisked me for my wallet. The one with the gun was sweating and very impatient that his partner couldn’t find my wallet fast enough. When they got what they wanted, they ran down to block to a waiting car in the next block.
Whenever you sense of yourself is presented with an unknown situation, your heartbeat increases. Not me. Curiously, I seemed to remain calm and relaxed during the episode. Actually, I remember feeling quite limp as one robber pushed his gun into my chest. After they were gone, I noticed my hands were shaking as I walked home.
In this discussion, I’m referring to everyday garden variety nerves, not to traumatic situations like a robbery.
Controlling “Stage Fright.” This emotional response is a good one, if you don’t let it take over your being. Some people – many actors – have difficulty controlling their “Stage Fright.” They go to therapy. They take courses in yoga. I know one person who goes to acupuncture to control her “Stage Fright.”
I believe that “Stage Fright” is a controllable emotional response. If you don’t believe it is controllable, then “Stage Fright” is not controllable for you and your nerves push you to the edge of sanity.
I believe that we all have the ability to choose. That’s what Eve’s apple gave us – for good or ill. If we have the freedom to choose, that we can choose to control “Stage Fright.”
I’m not saying it is an instant process. You don’t take a pill and suddenly you aren’t nervous.
Changing your responses is hard. Controlling “Stage Fright” is a learned process that begins in your head. You choose to learn how to control your responses. You practice by yourself or with a guide to make difference choices
Once you make the choice, then you begin to identify all the elements of “Stage Fright’ that you experience. When you are retraining your mind, you choose to change the response you have to a particular situation.
Sweaty palms, shaky hands and wobbly knees are only the symptoms of ‘Stage Fright.”
The process of retraining your responses can be long and demanding. Like an actor, you can teach yourself how to respond in controlled, directed manner. Your mental training allows you to use the nervous energy generated by “Stage Fright” to heighten your presentation.
Again, this doesn’t happen overnight. But once mastered, you are able to present yourself as more alert, more vibrant, more energetic, more enthusiastic, and more commanding in your presentation. Your nerves become a coiled spring, prepared to release upon your command.
As all communication competence begins with awareness, so does channeling “Stage Fright.”
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
December 9 – “Moral Decay and The Need for a Dress Code”– Recently, Charles Mason gave me a copy of an academic article entitled “Moral Crisis in Higher Education and the Dress Code Phenomenon.” The article reviews “indecent dressing among youth today” and “the need to restore high moral standards, integrity and decency.” In one of our recent sessions, the topic of saggy pants stirred up much discussion. Some people feel strongly – pro and con - about the way certain people dress. We try to keep calm during the session.
December 16 – “Thinking”- Do we know when we think? Can you NOT think? Do you know how YOU think? Do you like to think? Then what do you think about? How can you direct your thinking? What about distractions? These are only some of the topics that will probably come up during the discussion. Maybe someone will know how to read our minds.
Club sessions in the New Year; we’ll talk about when to schedule them.
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“Meaning”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Repetition”
“Cynicism”
“Heroism”
And dozens of others!
What happened on Wednesday, November 18, 2009? “SPAR Debate”
For today’s session, our group was small but fearless. . They included Richard Green, Carlisle Yearwood, Britzia Bolanos, Charles Mason, Ronald Johnson and Hal Wicke.
In the early part of the session, Richard, Carlisle and Hal worked with Britzia on her English facility. She is one of Richard’s ESL students and although very conversational in his class, she was brave in being willing to participate in a highly verbal environment.
The three teachers worked with her to explain the plot of Cervantes’ famous novel, “Don Quixote.” Who he was; who his sidekick was; what did the windmills represent; the symbolic meaning of his adventures. To ensure her comprehension, Richard translated the discussion into Spanish. Britzia listened carefully.
Later, Carlisle had to leave for an appointment, but before he left, he learned something from Richard – about his ability to listen. Clearly, the on-going lesson of these sessions is that everyone learns something, regardless of their background and conversational facility.
We took up the SPAR Debate topic of the day – “Honesty is the best policy.” After a flip of a coin, Richard took the negative side while Carlisle argued the affirmative position. Each went at each other in a ferocious, yet articulate exchange. There were a number of literary and biblical references combined with every day contemporary evidence.
Those present – Britzia and Ronald – each voted their favorite debater. The debate was a tie. Hal declined to vote because he was taking care of the mechanics.
In the debriefing, Richard commented on how much he learns from doing these instant debates because he is not used to getting all his thoughts together at one focused time.
We agree. So often we are thrown into situations where we would like to defend a point of view, but the words do not come fast enough or in an organized manner. Practice is the secret weapon for achieving this verbal facility.
We changed direction when Charles was interested in focusing on a comparison of \the current war in Afganistan with the war in Vietnam. He felt that Presidents Bush and Johnson were of the same mindset contrasted with President Obama’s decision making process:- a quick decision vs. a considered decision.
We will all find out next Tuesday night when Obama announces his plans at West Point. At the club meeting the next day, we’ll explore Obama’s injunction that he wants to “finish the job” in connection with our theme “Walking the talk.”
With Thanksgiving the next day and the building closing at 3 pm, the energy was focused on turkey. We will revisit SPAR Debate again in the New Year.
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.

Hal Wicke

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes - #96 –November 25, 2009
Communication Quote of the Week
If two men agree on everything,
you may be sure that one of them is doing the thinking.
Lyndon B. Johnson (1908 - 1973) was the 36th president of the U.S.
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, November 25, 2009 – Room 223
“SPAR Debate”
We need to return to practicing our Communication skills. This is another exercise to train your ability to think on your feet. You are given a topic – let’s say, “Honesty is the best policy.” You and a partner flip a coin for who is going to agree with the statement and who is going to disagree. You have a brief period to prepare, and then you argue you side. You will question your opponent and then restate your position. The audience will vote on who gave the best argument. They cannot take sides. To keep things lively, we have many other topics.
A Note to Communicators:
Finding Agreement #1
Strategy: To observe current events to discover important communication elements.
Tactic: To discover the elements of agreement and the difficulty in arriving at agreement in the current health care debate in Congress while trying not to take sides.
Finding agreement in any situation is at best difficult, at worst, impossible. The current health care debate is no exception – and it takes place mostly in public so we can examine some of the moving parts.
Goal: The nation has decided it wants a health care plan. Actually, President Obama is the one who put health care on his to-do list, along with 67 other issues. Obama is the instigator.
President Bush wasn’t interested in health care. President Clinton was, but botched the attempt in 1993 because he didn’t know how work the system. From the time of President Harry Truman in 1946, the health care has been an important issue.
Strategy: Identify what are the pieces you want in the bill. That’s the easy part.
· Be aware of what the other Democrats want in their plans.
· Be aware that the Republicans will probably vote against ANY Democratic health plan. (No Republican voted on Saturday night to close debate )
Tactic: Find allies who will support your bill or a compromise version of it/
Tactic: Anticipate the arguments against your bill and prepare your arguments for your bill.
Strategy: Recognize that certain members of Congress will not vote for your bill regardless of how good it is. In every past battle over social welfare issues (Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid), Republicans have consistently voted against these bills. In the current cloture vote, the Republicans voted in a bloc of all 39 votes. One Republican (Voinovich from Ohio) did not vote.
Opposing strategies for each side: If you are a Democrat, make sure all Democrats vote for the bill. If you are a Republican, make sure all the Republicans and a lot of Democrats don’t vote for the bill.
Tactics for both sides: The leadership of each party should divide up their opponents and decide what it will take to keep or change their vote. Have individual conversations with
Tactics for both sides: Appear in all media arguing for your side.
Tactics for both sides: Have the lobbyists from various industries who will benefit or destroy the support for or against the bill.
Final tactic – Call in all the favors from Members of Congress to vote the way you want.
Final strategy – Cross your fingers.
The above is roughly what happens in Congress in Washington or the Legislature in Albany. It is very formal and public.
In countries where the process of finding agreement is opaque (China) or violent (Afganistan or Iran), there are many more variables, especially is you decide to disagree with the leader of your country.
Most people tire easily of all this back and forth negotiation to arrive at an agreement. These people want simple solutions quickly. A dictator is the only kind of government they want – when THEY are the dictator.
Any kind of democracy is torturous – especially is interpersonal relationships. If we think we believe in equality, just wait until someone disagrees with you. Then it’s “My way or the highway!”
We aren’t taught negotiation is school. Power is the only thing that comes instinctively to us. A knife, a gun or a fist can solve an immediate problem, but – DAMN! – There are all these pesky consequences – unfair treatment, lies, hurt feelings, emotional damage, etc. etc. Even verbal manipulation is a weapon for those who have fast mouths.
But that gets tiresome. What to do?
Sir Winston Churchill once said, “Democracy is the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried.”
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
December 2 – “Walking the Talk”- Many of us have had the experience of knowing people who promise to do something and don’t do it. This experience can be personal or within a group. A Touro Dean once described two categories of participants in a project. “There are the show horses and there are the work horses.” The show horses talk a good game, but they “don’t deliver the mail,” as one member of Congress recently phrased it. There are dozens of ways this situation occurs. We’ll share our experiences and then discuss what to do about the phenomenon.
December 9 – “Moral Decay and The Need for a Dress Code”– Recently, Charles Mason gave me a copy of an academic article entitled “Moral Crisis in Higher Education and the Dress Code Phenomenon.” The article reviews “indecent dressing among youth today” and “the need to restore high moral standards, integrity and decency.” In one of our recent sessions, the topic of saggy pants stirred up much discussion. Some people feel strongly – pro and con - about the way certain people dress. We try to keep calm during the session.
December 16 – “Thinking”- Do we know when we think? Can you NOT think? Do you know how YOU think? Do you like to think? Then what do you think about? How can you direct your thinking? What about distractions? These are only some of the topics that will probably come up during the discussion. Maybe someone will know how to read our minds.
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“Meaning”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Repetition”
“Cynicism”
“Heroism”
And dozens of others!
What happened on Wednesday, November 18, 2009? “Charles Borkhuis and his Radio Plays”
For today’s program, we had a healthy mixture of new and familiar faces, mostly faculty. The new faces were Mirela Burca, Lacy Shaw, and Leon Perkal. Among the familiar faces were Richard Green, Lorinda Moore, Meggy Lindsay, Abraham Luna, James Millner, Charles Mason, Pamela Sheppard, Markus Vayndorf, Rene Vasquez, Carlisle Yearwood, Jean Missial and Hal Wicke And, of course, Charles Borkhuis, our guest for the afternoon.
The purpose of this session was to be able to hear a work of art and then question the working artist, who happens to teach at Touro, to discover how he does what he does.
English faculty member Charles Borkhuis leads several creative lives outside of Touro. In addition to his poetry and essays, his many radio and stage plays have received national and international acclaim.
During the afternoon, we listened to two 26-minute radio plays of Charles Borkhuis which were performed on National Public Radio. We listened to “The Sound of Fear Clapping” and “Foreign Bodies.”
Each was homage to the Hollywood film noir genre of the 1940s and early ‘50s, which was rooted in German Expressionism of the 1920s. Drawing on the literary detective novels of Raymond Chandler and Mickey Spillane, these movies starred familiar names of Humphrey Bogart, Edward G. Robinson, Sidney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre. Some film noir titles might include “The Maltese Falcon,” “Key Largo,” and “The Asphalt Jungle,” which reappear occasionally on Turner Classic Movies (TCM).
Professor Borkhuis said he was inspired to write these radio plays from his childhood experiences of listening to radio drama like “The Lone Ranger,” “The Adventures of Sam Spade,” and radio comedies like “Abbott and Costello,” “Amos ‘n’ Andy.” Several faculty also remembered these radio shows with great warmth.
The old-time radio plays may have been the inspiration for Professor Borkhuis, but what he does with the format and its elements completely reinvents the genre. .
To retell the plots of both plays after one hearing is, for this reporter, an impossibility. In each, a gravelly-voiced central male character narrates his difficulties with time, people and
.Professor Borkhuis creates a riveting aural portrait that mimics its origins while transcending its limits. The voices and the music painted a tortured central figure which is at the mercy of forces beyond his control.
Unlike its film noir inspiration with its linear plot and stereotypical characters, he manipulated time and, with sound overlays, was able to create a simultaneity that the old-time radio plays had never envisioned.
With a long list of books of poetry to his credit, the poet in Borkhuis manipulates his radio language to heighten the impact of the story. Narration, dialogue and repetition of key phrases create a complex verbal portrait of the entanglements of the principal character. Occasional contemporary references were jarring opposition to the 1940s mood he created.
Between each radio play, everyone asked questions of Professor Borkhuis, ranging from the mechanics of production to how he got his ideas for the two shows. He was very gracious in answering every question in detail. The second play, “Foreign Bodies,” had a jazz theme and Professor Borkhuis pointed out several moments where the structure of jazz music was reinforced by the music of jazz.
· “For me,” Professor Borkhuis commented, “Poetry is an escape into an imaginary world that is always new.” Other thoughts included:
· “As adults we have lost that atmosphere of a child’s world.”
· “There are poetic moments in washing dishes.”
· “A Zen answer not far from the dreaming world.”
· “Awareness is a new day.”
· “Get into the state – the spell – James Joyce’s ‘Epiphany.’”
· “I look for a spark. I read bits from 12 books until something, a voice, triggers a spark.”
· “There are a lot of choices which I have to edit, particularly to a 26 minute format.”
· “The spiral is an image of human projection, going forward yet returning to previous themes.”
Professor Borkhuis: “I was working with a student the other day. I asked her to write her ideas randomly on the board. These thoughts are bubbles. We then began to work to make connections between and among the bubbles to make a coherent paragraph.”
· “There is a value in repetition.”
· Yearwood: “Sliding between your own thoughts.”
· “You establish a dream spell and then prime the pump. The mind works associatively.”
· “I enjoy my teaching – it is a stimulating, creative process.”
How long did you take to write these plays? “Picasso was asked the same question about one of his paintings. He said, “Sixty-seven years.”
· “The product is the process…a pebble on the road becomes gold.”
· “Sound and silence over music.”
· “Leave your egos at the door.”
Jean gave an interesting final thought: “I always think in terms of ends – the products. I think I have to work on the beginnings and middles as well.”
As the group concludes, everyone applauded Professor Borkhuis. “Exhilarating!” “Wonderful!” “The best program yet!” were among the many, many comments
For those interested in hearing Charles Borkhuis’ two radio plays, here is the link:
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.

Hal Wicke