Sunday, October 11, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes #91 –October 7, 2009
Communication Quote of the Week
“Anytime four New Yorkers get into a cab together without arguing, a bank robbery has just taken place.”
Johnny Carson, the late comedian, was host of “The Tonight Show starring Johnny Carson” for thirty years. During his career, he won six Emmy Awards, a Peabody Award and received the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1992.
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, October 14, 2009 – Room 223
“Civility”
Several weeks ago, Hal wrote about “On Civility” in this blog. In August, we saw a Congressman yell, “You lie!” during a speech by President Obama. We watched a month of yelling in August with the health care “debates.” We saw professional tennis players Serena Williams and Roger Federer behave badly when they lost. The Pittsburgh G20 summit showed more evidence of incivility. Comedian Dave Letterman announces his pre-marital affairs during his show. Elected officials continue to betray their wives. A student shouts in a class that he is right and they are wrong. Incivility occurs at all levels of society. How do we recognize it? Why does it occur? Is incivility just part of our life? How do we handle incivility when it is directed at us? Are we always uncivil at times?
A Note to Communicators:
The Effects of an Argument Culture
Strategy: To notice patterns of communication behavior and deconstruct these verbal and non-verbal behaviors.
Tactic: To become more aware of the factors that affect and filter communication.
This week’s entry takes its cue from the 1999 book “The Argument Culture” by linguist Deborah Tannen. The subtitle is “Moving from Debate to Dialogue.” Tannen is one of a very small handful of public intellectuals who are interested in communication issues. With several books focused on communication issues for women, Dr. Tannen’s 2009 book is You Were Always Mom's Favorite!: Sisters in Conversation Throughout Their Lives
Even ten years after Tannen’s book, the “argument culture” still prevails in American public life. Last summer saw a number of incidents which highlights how argumentative public figures can be when they are met with disagreement or something they don’t like. Perhaps we should consider “argument” as an endemic part of the civil structure we call “democracy.” If we are to accept that “all men [and women] are equal,” then don’t we have to accept the reality that we will not agree on everything – or anythingsometimes. Why does this occur?
One view is that our culture does intrinsically support a binary view of the world. Some examples may support this view.
· Everything is either/or, rarely both/and.
· If you don’t win, you lose.
· In a world that is getting faster every moment, there is no time for shades of gray.
· You are either right or you are wrong.
· If you have a nuanced point of view, the noise from the opposition will drown out you and your ideas.
Even President Obama’s receipt of the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize this week has generated for and against positions. Who ever heard of a middle ground?
All our models for discourse are binary: On/off switches without dimmers. There are only two major political parties. Sports teams win or lose. Courts of law are win/lose arenas. My religion is the only one; other religions are wrong.
As Green Bay Packer’s legendary coach, Vince Lombardi, once said, “Winning isn’t everything; it’s the only thing,” On a football field, such singularity of purpose is very important.
However, that lesson leaves the athletic field and carries into our daily life. We have only two options in our lives: win or lose.
· “If I don’t get an A, I fail. A B is not acceptable.”< /FONT>
· ““If I don’t get an A, I’m a terrible person.”
· “If I don’t win the Lotto, I’m a loser.”
· “If I don’t win, I must be wrong.”
· If I don’t leap a tall building at a single bound, I’m a failure.”
The psychology beneath these outlooks is for the psychologists, not communicators. We focus on the operational aspects of communication. Whatever the psychology, the two-choice-only option ratchets up an enormous tension.
Such a world view lends itself to argument. More importantly, you must be right in your world view, or you are embarrassed by being wrong.
Proof – evidence – is primary in a binary world. As René Descartes has conditioned us to believe, we delete emotions as any factor in proving your “rational” point that is syllogistically proved.
But emotions are powerful forces. Unless we sit on them, they escape and infect our pristine rational position. It is at this vulnerable moment that powerful emotions replace any chance of reason dominating a disagreement. Then an argument explodes.
All of this discussion is but a first draft of a much larger communication issue. As I reread what I’ve just written, there are many gaps in the sequence of my words. I have to spend another time filling out this sketch.
Since I would support Tannen’s outlook that we live in a c ulture of argument, perhaps I could proceed in a couple of directions. I could continue to bemoan this vitriolic atmosphere, adding more examples and some history. I could explore alternatives to argument, particularly those of dialogue which accept differences among and between people and work toward commonalities, Or I could try briefly to how to understand this dichotomous environment and find ways to move toward more productive outcomes.
I’ll explore briefly the third option. I will start with a basic statement: “All people are different.” I’m pretty sure that no one will disagree with this cliché. If that axiom is true, then it should follow that we are different in many ways. Even twins are different.
Without belaboring the point, we need to realize that, although we accept that we are all different, we expect others to behave the same way as we do. We have a mental flip to “know” one thing in the abstract, but “expect” that we should behave identically=2 0– almost.
Perhaps we’ll accept differences from A to B, but beyond B, things become dicey. The idea needs further exploration, but as communicators we must realize that we don’t live in that ideal world where everyone believes and behaves as we do.
Our continuing challenge is how to recognize differences quickly, accept them, understand them and, if you and your partner choose, mediate them toward a productive outcome.
As always, our first requirement is to be awake.
:”Our spirits are c orroded by living in an atmosphere of unrelenting contention – the argument culture.” [Deborah Tannen, “The Argument Culture” p. 3]
The subtitle of Tannen’s book, “Moving from Debate to Dialogue” is a rich area to explore.
To be continued – sometime.
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
October 21 – “The Seven Deadly Sins”- Originating with the Greeks and codified by the Catholic Church in the Dark Ages, these seven human behaviors are thought to be central to our difficulties in the world. Unfortunately, today we take these behaviors as the norm. We’ll explore as many as time allows. They include: lust, gluttony, greed, sloth, wrath, envy and pride.
October 21 – “Entitlement” Do you believe in “entitlement”? You believe that you are deserving of or entitled to certain privileges. Are you entitled to “respect”? Are you entitled to an A grade in every course? Are you entitled to say, “I am King”? (Sean John’s new men’s fragrance). Does fame make you entitled? Because you are male or female, does that make you e ntitled? What are the criteria for being “entitled”? Another complex topic that shows up in the words we choose and the behavior we use.
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Thinking”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
”SPAR Debate”
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“Communication Lessons from Martial Arts”
“Meaning”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Charles Borkhuis and his Radio Plays”
And dozens of others!
What happened on Wednesday, October 7, 2009? “Giving Criticism”
Newcomer Iris Hymowitz was game in sharing her views with Erica Bell, Drani Gabu, Donne Kampel, Carlisle Yearwood, Gary Sheinfeld, Markus Vayndorf, Lorinda Moore, Meggy Lindsay, Charles Mason, Ronald Johnson and Hal Wicke
Hal wrote a few questions on the board:
· What is criticism?
· What kinds of criticism are there?
· What gives you the right to give criticism to someone?
· Is there such a thing as “constructive criticism”?
· When do you give criticism?
· How do you do it?
Some responses to “When do you give criticism?”
· When something is wrong.
· When I am annoyed.
· I’m just expressing my opinion.
· I’m trying to improve ideas.
When you give criticism, do you find yourself in a particular role that gives you the “right” to give criticism?
· A person of recognized authority - teacher, boss, police officer
· Criticism is part of the job.
· Students expect criticism from teachers which is “respectful.”
· A parent to child. What about a parent to a child of someone else?
Lorinda cited an incident on the train where she approached several people who were swearing loudly, suggesting that they should not use profanity – there were other ways of expressing themselves.
What if you don’t have any of these roles?
Two people said “I give it anyway because my boss was wrong and I knew better.” One said she was suspended for insubordination and later left her job.
You have the right to criticize when you are someone’s friend. Lots of disagreement
Criticism becomes. advice in a job interview, “You’d better wear more appropriate clothes to work here.” Particularly in a job situation where shared values are important to achieve a common goal.
Where does “power” enter the equation?
· A person “should” do something – says who?
· The student challenges the teacher on a specific point or a point of view. “You all are wrong and I am right,” says a student to the class
What about “power distance”? [The phenomena of the power built into hierarchy and superior/inferior relationships.]
· Boss/employee.
· Officer/enlisted person.
· Teacher/student.
· Parent/child.
Or arguable power distance relationships of women being superior to men and the reverse or racial and ethnic relationships where one race or culture is superior to another.
Gary described an instance where two people were 0making out” during the movie “Schindler’s List.” There are certain expectations in specific circumstances – inappropriate behavior in a place of worship, or in a class.
The pattern of incidents discussed seemed to be that conflict occurred when one or more persons were sufficiently absorbed in his/their world (living in a bubble?) to be unaware of or deliberately defying the prevailing value system in the environment. If “Life is all about me,” then it is likely that there will be conflict and hostility when that person(s) is criticized.
Drani spoke about growing up in Sudan and learning that politics, money and religion were not subjects to be discussed because there would be trouble. Hal suggested that sexual issues be included in the list of difficult topics in a ”polite” conversation. To bring such a topic up, Drani said, would create many problems.
Hal brought up the international incident several years ago when the satirical cartoons making fun of Islam’s founder were published in a Danish newspaper and caused riots and at least one killing in Denmark and other countries.
The discussion moved to the Jewish Holocaust and one question asked by a student, “How many people have to die to have a holocaust?”
Markus defined criticism as “an objective reaction to what does not work and have both physical and logical aspects.” He continued his explanation at the blackboard and the group seemed not to follow his lecture.
Clearly tired at this point, the group seemed to lose focus. Among the topics that were tossed about:
· The idea of exploring “constructive criticism” was lost in lots of cross-talk.
· Criticizing professors .and bosses – everyone has that right.
· Professors with accents who cannot be understood
· “Everyone has the right to criticize anyone.” Lots of discussion here.
· Cautions; Think twice before you speak. Be calm, Step out of the situation
· Erica’s Mom’s saying, “A closed mouth doesn’t get fed.”
· Pick your battles.
· Non-verbal clues like sustained eye contact create negative critical environments.
· One person’s criticism is another’s advice.
Like many of our discussions, this one on criticism was beginning to scratch the surface as we ran out of energy. Perhaps at some point we can become more disciplined in keeping our focus narrowed on an area until we exhaust its possibilities. Too often we skip from topic to topic – interesting at the moment, but distracting from fully understanding what other people are saying.
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.

Hal Wicke

Sunday, October 4, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes #90 –October 7, 2009
Communication Quote of the Week
Dedicated to those who open their mouths:
He who knows not and knows not that he knows not, is a fool.
But he who knows not and knows that he knows not is a very wise man."
Mr. Raymond Bardwell, of Kansas City, MO, is well known for being the father of Ms. Gena Bardwell, 
currently of the Touro College Communication Department in New York City. Mr. Bardwell’s wise sayings
are legion and his wisdom is legendary in the Bardwell clan. The quotation was generated by our recent 
discussion on “Knowing.” 
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, October 7, 2009 – Room 223< /div>
“Giving Criticism”-
We all do it. We criticize our bosses, our teachers, our parents, our friends. Why do we do it? How do we do it? When do we give criticism? Why do we do it behind people’s backs? Is there such a thing as ‘Constructive Criticism’? This topic is an emotional time-bomb. We’ll discuss why and how we can do it more productively.
A Note to Communicators:
Factors that Affect Communication
Strategy: To notice patterns of communication behavior and deconstruct these verbal and non-verbal behaviors.
Tactic: To become more aware of the factors that affect and filter communication.
Most of the time we are concerned about getting our message across to the person in front of us – our child ren, our lover, our co-worker, our boss and so on. When we speak to another, it is almost as if we put blinders on and forget about our peripheral vision.
We also put blinders on all the factors that form the context of our message. We focus on the content of the message. We are unaware of what is going on non-verbally as we speak. Are we aware of our facial expressions? Our vocal inflections (paralanguage)? Our body language (kinesics)?
I think not. We are unlike actors. They are trained to be aware of these contextual factors, but they don’t have to worry about the message. The playwright has taken care of that.
An ideal for an individual’s communication vision is to become aware of all the external AND internal factors in a message AS the message was being delivered. An enormous task that begins with fundamental awareness.
With Jude Law playing “Hamlet” on Broadway now. I am reminded of part of Hamlet’s speech to Horatio at the end of the graveyard scene (Act V Scene ii).
…There's a special providence in the fall of a sparrow. If it be now, 'tis not to come; if it be not to come, it will be now; if it be not now, yet it will come: the readiness is all.
“The readiness is all” is what counts in Hamlet’s pursuit of vengeance. We must be prepared in our daily life. If we aren’t, we have smaller personal versions of 9/11/09 or Vietnam or 12/7/41, Are we ready for the commitment to winning the war in Afghanistan? No one has in their tragic history of invading armies.
Whoops! I digressed. Back to the personal level. We must be aware of the baggage we carry in our communication messages, baggage which leaks into our exchanges. We must be aware of the person we are speaking to and what we can figure out of their own baggage.
If “readiness is all” in all our communication dealings, we must be aware of the impact of culture, belief systems, gender, power and emotion which filter every message we deliver.
A tall requirement for mere “readiness." Perhaps we should take the Buddhist approach and empty ourselves of Western concepts of self.
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
October 14 – “Civility” – Several weeks ago, this blogger wrote about “On Civility.” The Pittsburgh G20 summit this past week is another evidence of incivility. President Obama commented that the demonstrations were “mild” compared to past G20 summits. Incivility occurs at all levels of society. How do we recognize it? Is incivility just part of our life? How do we handle incivility when it is directed at us? Are we uncivil at times?
October 21 – “The Seven Deadly Sins”- Originating with the Greeks and codified by the Catholic Church in the Dark Ages, these seven human behaviors are thought to be central to our difficulties in the world. Unfortunately, today we take these behaviors as=2 0the norm. We’ll explore as many as time allows. They include: lust, gluttony, greed, sloth, wrath, envy and pride.
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Thinking”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
”SPAR Debate”
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“Communication Lessons from Martial Arts”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Charles Borkhuis and his Radio Plays”
And dozens of others!
What happened on Wednesday, September 16, 2009? “Elevator Speeches”
Newcomer Jason Tavarez had no trouble joining in the spirited exchange among regulars Robert Bohr, Drani Gabu, Carlisle Yearwood, Charles Mason, Markus Vayndorf and Hal Wicke.
Hal described the “Elevator Speech” as an impromptu presentation on a specific topic usually lasting around 30 seconds. The format takes its name from a situation where you meet someone of importance at an elevator and have about 30 seconds to summarize your thoughts in the time it takes the elevator to rise to its final destination.
Typical “Elevator Speeches” might be a job introduction, a product summary, a proposal for a change in a way of doing something. The impromptu speeches given at weddings, bar/bas mitzvahs and other celebrations are other occasions.
Most importantly, the exercise teaches us to think on our feet under pressure.
Hal shared his sudden use of the elevator speech format just that morning when he chose to explain the developing program on Experiential Learning to an important potential supporter.
The group began with the all important audience analysis. If we have the chance to prepare before speaking, we should do a quick demographic analysis of the audience. An analysis of our group documented quickly 5 males, one female, 4 faculty, 2 students, 3 born outside U.S. and various ages.
The analysis might have gone into more depth if we were to orchestrate a marketing and PR campaign of a new idea, product or service with focus groups. Politicians, religious figures, and teachers sell ideas. Doctors, lawyers, electricians and garage repair people sell services. Inventors, manufacturers and store owners sell products. A focus group will better help the marketer understand the audience to whom the campaign is directed.
We explored how various people discovered the Communication Club. Word of mouth was the most prevalent way the club was marketed to the group.
During the discussion, one person called Touro students “products.” Another student took great except ion to being called a product: “I am a human being.” Others raised the idea that Touro students were a “product” of their education.
The student remained adamant in her view, despite acknowledging that a student could be a “product” – the culmination -of her Touro education.
We got sidetracked - this is very easy to do in our discussions – on the White House intrusion into the NY State Governor’s race with its pressuring Governor Patterson not to run.
We focused on how different each Touro site was from the other. Some sites made a demonstrably better impression than others.
In the discussion, it became cl ear that most people were reacting to externals while suggesting the internals – the teaching – was about the same. Carlisle exclaimed that when he saw the architecture at City College as a student, he was “sold.”
There was a vigorous discussion of the many factors which contribute to the students’ perception of their education. As the discussion finished, the group was figuring out concrete ways to improve their perceptions.
Happily, the best outcome of a good discussion is always movement toward some action.
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.

Hal Wicke

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

The Touro Communication Club Notes #89 – September 30, 2009
Communication Quote of the Week
“The difference between the almost right word and the right word is really a large matter – ‘tis the difference between the lightning bug and lightning.”
Mark Twain, pseudonym of Samuel Langhorne Clemens, 1835–1910, American author. As humorist, narrator, and social observer, Twain is unsurpassed in American literature. His novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, a masterpiece of humor, characterization, and realism, has been called the first (and sometimes the best) modern American novel. (Columbia Encyclopedia)
The Touro Communication Club
2 pm - Wednesday, September 30, 2009 – Room 223
“Elevator Speeches”
We need to practice thinking on our feet. We did impromptu speaking in the spring. The “Elevator Speech”is a specific “speech” you develop in advance of needing to give it. It lasts about 30 seconds, the typical time it takes an elevator to rise to its floor. Typical “Elevator Speeches” are a job introduction, a product summary, a proposal for a change in a way of doing something.
A Note to Communicators:
Language Matters
Strategy: To notice patterns of communication behavior and deconstruct these verbal and non-verbal behaviors
Tactic: To develop tactics to counter or at least to neutralize negative communication behavior.
The longer I am involved with communication, the more I realize how complicated it is. We say something we think is ok, but the other person gets angry or hurt. We write things – even twitter messages with its reductionist demands of 140 characters – and we get misunderstood.
Why does this continue to happen? My guess is that we often speak without thinking of the impact of our words on our audience. If you are a politician or public figure every move and word is under the media microscope 24/7. Even President Obama, who is an acknowledged master of words, has made a couple of faux pas on national television. When he gives a speech , you notice he’s reading a script.
Mark Twain’s quotation at the top of the blog highlights the difficulty in finding the “right” word. But in our ordinary conversation, I’m not sure we are as careful as we might be.
Not only are we not as careful as we might, we are so often preoccupied with ourselves we don’t even notice that we haven’t picked the right word – not to say even the “approximately accurate” word.
We shoot from the lip in most of our communication transactions. That works most of the time, but then there are times when we need to be more careful in our language choice. These situations occur when the stakes of how we communicate are raised – a job interview, a comment in class, a love relationship – and especially when we speak at the United Nations.
How do we attempt to say what we mean? We’ve got to make sure we think about what your message is going to include before you send it to your mouth for external distribution.
Easier said than done. You have to think about the audience to whom you are sending your message. You have to be aware if certain words might trigger unwelcome responses. You have be prepared for unanticipated responses which your words have generated.
Sounds like you’ve got to walk on eggs all the time. I don’t think so. However, thinking and awareness do help in a pinch.
If you are operating in a narcissistic bubble where you are the center of world, you need only to shoot from t he lip when you want. Who cares about consequences? It’s only your world that counts.
Most of us can’t afford to for long to operate in a bubble – not enough money, not a big enough posse, not enough paparazzi, not enough power. When our communication repeatedly explodes in our face, should we consider modifying our vocabulary? I would hope so.
Then again, we all know people who never become aware of how they communicate. If these people are important to us, we need to devise a different set of strategies to cope with them. If they are useful to us only on occasion, we need to develop ways to ensure our ideas are not trampled on. If they are not important to us, we need to realize that these people need to quickly become history in our lives.
UPCOMING CONVERSATIONS:
October 7 - “Giving Criticism”- We all do it. We criticize our bosses, our teachers, our parents, our friends. Why do we do it? How do we do it? When do we give criticism? This topic is an emotional time-bomb. We’ll discuss why and how we can do it more productively.
October 14 – “Civility” – Several weeks ago, this blogger wrote about “On Civility.” The Pittsburgh G20 summit this past week is another evidence of incivility. President Obama commented that the demonstrations were “mild” compared to past G20 summits. Incivility occurs at all levels of society. How do we recognize it? Is incivility just part of our life? How do we handle incivility when it is directed at us? Are we uncivil at times?
What about one of these topics?
“How Do You Fire Someone?”
“Thinking”
“Rap and Hip Hop – What’s the Message?"
”SPAR Debate”
“Rodney King: ‘Why Can’t We Get Along?”
“Asking Questions in Class”
“Cold Calling in Sales”
“The Seven Deadly Sins”
“The Seven Heavenly Virtues”
“Why Does History Repeat Itself?”
“Charles Borkhuis and his radio plays”
And dozens of others!
What happ ened on Wednesday, September 16, 2009? “How do you know you don’t understand? How do you know anything?”
Newcomer Abraham Luna quickly joined in the spirit of the group which included Markus Vayndorf, Gary Sheinfeld, Carlisle Yearwood, Charles Mason, Ronald Johnson, Jose Dunker, Lorinda Moore, Meggy Lindsay and Hal Wicke.
Hal described a familiar situation he experienced in class where he was sure he knew what the assignment was until he realized he didn’t understand it. He keeps asking himself, “How do I know what I know? Do I really understand what I’ve read or heard?”
A variety comments followed.
· It’s like riding a bike. You can’t learn to ride a bike from a book.
· If you can’t “do” it, you don’t know it. [whatever “it” is.]
· Paraphrase what you think you’ve heard or read to verify that you understand the information.
· Knowledge and language are always intermingled [Gary ]
· You have the concept and then its application.
· There are 2 parts to knowledge: common sense knowledge and academic knowledge [Markus]
· Knowledge as instrumental and knowledge as feeling. [Gary]
· There is experience beyond knowledge. Beyond a certain point, you can’t explain it with words (Carlisle).
· Immanuel Kant – there is a gap between imagination and cognition [Gary]
· “I don’t understand what you’re talking about” says one student, rolling his eyes.
· Gary tells the joke of the talking dog. No one laughs. “Cognition is not there while you are laughing.”
· Art transcends words.
· There are a variety of perceptions – rational, irrational and non-rational.
· Innate perception – animals run when the forest is on fire [Gary]
· A poem is a linguistic perception of the physical.
· Are we all Pavlov’s dogs? We are influenced by our social environment.
· Why does a school of sardines act as one when swimming? [Gary]
· Jose told of his grandmother who controlled the family with a flick of her eyebrows.
· We resist anything that we do not believe in.
· Two spoke about two different reactions to the rules of their households. One followed them to the letter. The other rebelled yet took the punishment for not obeying.
· Carlisle brought up “Seth Speaks,” an alternative view of reality that was “channeled” through a medium. It scared the daylights out of him.
· Animals change when they are threatened by a predator. Animals have not choice. They are programmed.
· Knowing, thinking and doing are important parts of our daily life [Ron]
· If we have a “gut” feeling, we need to verify it.
· Paraphrase to20verify. Ask the teacher.
· When there is understanding, there is a release of energy
· Do you watch body language?
Awareness needs to be sharpened in order to behave calmly when the five senses are overwhelmed and merge into our worldview. A never ending process.
Markus bid us adieu in his grand manner saying, E2I know I have to teach a class now.”
We always have a great time exploring these issues. So often our daily life never focuses on these Communication issues. If you have something you want us to discuss please let us know and we’ll add it to the list.
Next time bring a friend. The Communication Club is always an open discussion, limited only by time. Everyone gets a chance to speak. All opinions are welcome. Here is an opportunity for students to challenge professors’ views outside the class without any homework or assignments. You just have to show up and listen and talk if you want.